Key Takeaways
Before diving in, here are some important ideas worth considering:
- Piano exams can be valuable and provide structure, goals and clear milestones.
- Exams are one pathway through music education, not the only pathway.
- Different students are motivated by different musical outcomes.
- Contemporary musicianship focuses on skills such as rhythm, harmony, improvisation, creativity and practical music-making.
- The most important goal is long-term musical development rather than any individual assessment result.
A Question Many Parents Eventually Ask
At some point, many parents find themselves asking a similar question:
“What if my teenager doesn’t want to do piano exams?”
Sometimes a student has completed exams for several years and no longer feels enthusiastic about them. Sometimes they have never shown much interest in examinations at all. In other cases, parents worry that without exams there will be no structure, no goals and no way to measure progress.
It’s a reasonable question.
For generations, examinations have been a central part of piano education. As a result, many people naturally associate piano learning with grades, certificates and assessment pathways.
However, the relationship between exams and musical growth is often more nuanced than it first appears.
Exams Are One Pathway, Not the Only Pathway
One of the most important things to understand is that exams are a pathway.
They are not the destination.
Examination systems provide structure, progression and clear milestones. They encourage students to develop skills systematically and can create a strong sense of achievement when goals are reached.
For many students, this works extremely well.
At the same time, it’s worth remembering that an examination is ultimately a snapshot. It reflects a student’s performance on a particular day under a particular set of circumstances. Like any assessment, factors such as confidence, nerves, preparation and even how a student is feeling that week can influence the outcome.
Because of this, I tend to view examination results as useful information rather than definitive statements about a student’s musical ability.
A strong result deserves to be celebrated. Equally, a disappointing result does not erase the skills, understanding and musical growth that may have occurred throughout the learning process.
The learning still matters.
Different Students Are Motivated By Different Things
One thing I’ve noticed over many years of teaching is that students are not all motivated in the same way.
Some teenagers thrive when they have a clearly defined goal. They enjoy preparing for an assessment, working through a graded syllabus and achieving measurable milestones.
Other students are motivated by different outcomes.
They may want to:
- play songs they enjoy
- accompany themselves singing
- improvise
- play in bands
- write music
- understand harmony
- develop practical musicianship
These students are not necessarily less committed to music.
Often, they’re simply inspired by a different destination.
That’s an important distinction because motivation tends to be strongest when the learning pathway aligns with what the student genuinely wants to achieve.
The Certificate Versus the Development
Another aspect of examinations worth considering is how success is measured.
At their best, examination systems are designed to support musical growth. The graded structure exists for a reason. Each level introduces new techniques, concepts and challenges that help students build skills progressively over time.
The intention is not simply to collect certificates.
The intention is to develop musicianship.
Occasionally, however, the focus can shift. Parents and students can become more interested in the certificate than the learning the certificate is intended to represent. In some cases, there may even be pressure to move through grades as quickly as possible.
The challenge with that mindset is that music is not a race.
Whether a student is following a classical pathway, a contemporary pathway or a combination of both, strong foundations matter. Musical growth occurs when skills are given time to develop properly.
One of the strengths of systems such as AMEB is that they were designed to build musicianship progressively within the classical tradition. Each grade introduces building blocks intended to support future development. When viewed this way, examinations become a valuable educational framework rather than a collection of certificates.
The certificate is not the musicianship.
It is simply evidence that certain aspects of musicianship have been demonstrated at a particular point in time.
Exams Measure Some Skills Exceptionally Well
It’s also important to acknowledge what examinations do well.
Exams often provide opportunities to develop:
- music reading
- technical control
- repertoire preparation
- performance confidence
- disciplined practice
- structured progression
These are valuable musical skills.
Students who engage seriously with examination systems often develop strong foundations in these areas, and many continue to benefit from those skills throughout their lives.
For some teenagers, exams provide exactly the structure and motivation they need.
That’s why I see exams as a valuable option within music education rather than something that should automatically be embraced or rejected.
Some Musical Skills Are Harder to Measure
Many of the skills used in real-world music making are less straightforward to assess formally.
For example:
- accompanying singers
- learning music by ear
- improvising
- creating arrangements
- playing in bands
- writing songs
- responding to other musicians
- adapting in performance situations
These areas often involve judgement, creativity, listening and musical interaction.
They’re no more important than examination skills, but they’re not always as easy to measure with a grade or mark.
That doesn’t make them any less valuable.
In fact, these are often the skills students continue using throughout adulthood when they participate in music outside formal educational settings.
The Question I Prefer to Ask
When parents ask whether their teenager should do exams, I often find myself considering a different question.
Rather than asking:
“Should they sit exams?”
I think it’s often more helpful to ask:
“What kind of musician do they want to become?”
That question shifts the focus from assessment towards outcome.
A student pursuing a traditional classical pathway may find examinations highly beneficial.
A student interested in improvisation, accompaniment, songwriting, band performance or broader contemporary musicianship may benefit from a pathway that allocates more time to those skills.
Neither approach is inherently superior.
The pathway should support the destination.
Learning Without Exams Still Requires Commitment
Some people assume that choosing a non-exam pathway makes learning easier.
In my experience, that’s rarely the case.
Students developing contemporary musicianship still need to practise. They still need to build skills gradually, solve musical problems and work through challenges over time.
The difference is often where the effort is directed.
Students may be working on:
- rhythm and groove
- harmonic understanding
- improvisation
- accompaniment
- ear training
- creativity
- learning songs
- performing with others
The commitment remains.
The goals simply look different.
What Happens After School?
One reason I encourage parents to think broadly about musical outcomes is that most teenagers eventually leave school and enter a world where music often works differently.
A student might join a university band.
They may accompany singers, participate in community music groups, play in a church team, write songs or simply continue making music with friends.
Many of these situations rely heavily on practical musicianship.
They require listening, adaptability, rhythm, harmony, confidence and the ability to interact musically with other people.
These are precisely the kinds of skills contemporary musicianship aims to develop.
Not because every student will pursue music professionally.
But because these skills help students participate meaningfully in music long after formal lessons have finished.
Why This Matters
Exams can be excellent.
They provide structure, goals and a proven pathway for many students.
At the same time, they represent one approach to musical development rather than the entirety of music education.
Some students thrive within examination systems.
Others thrive through a broader exploration of rhythm, harmony, creativity, improvisation and practical music-making.
The important thing is not whether a student collects certificates.
The important thing is whether they continue developing as a musician.
Because ultimately, the goal is not simply to pass an exam.
It’s to build the skills, understanding and confidence that allow someone to enjoy music for life.
Contemporary Piano Lessons on Sydney’s North Shore
Contemporary piano lessons are available across Sydney’s North Shore, including St Ives, Pymble, Gordon, Killara, Lindfield, Roseville, Chatswood, Turramurra, Wahroonga and Hornsby.
Lessons focus on helping students develop practical piano skills through rhythm, harmony, creativity, improvisation, playing by ear and contemporary styles including pop, blues and jazz. Online lessons are also available via Microsoft Teams.
A Warm Invitation
Every teenager’s musical journey is unique.
Some thrive within formal examination systems. Others find their passion through improvisation, creativity, accompaniment or practical musicianship.
If you’re unsure which pathway best suits your teenager, a conversation can often provide valuable clarity.
If you’d like to discuss contemporary piano lessons, examinations, musicianship, or the goals you have for your teenager’s musical development, feel free to email Dave Halls and start the conversation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick Answer
No. Many excellent musicians have developed through a variety of pathways. Exams are one valuable option, not the only one.
Expanded Answer
Examinations can provide goals, structure and useful benchmarks throughout a student’s development. They are a respected and proven component of music education.
However, musicianship develops through many experiences. Listening, performing, improvising, accompanying, creating music and working with other musicians all contribute to musical growth.
The most important question is not whether a student sits exams. It’s whether they are continuing to develop meaningful skills and understanding over time.
Quick Answer
Absolutely. Contemporary musicianship and examinations can complement each other very effectively.
Expanded Answer
Many students successfully combine examination preparation with broader musicianship development.
Skills such as harmony, rhythm, listening, improvisation and musical understanding often strengthen a student’s overall musical capability, regardless of whether exams form part of their pathway.
It doesn’t have to be an either-or decision.
For many students, the strongest approach includes elements of both.
Quick Answer
Not necessarily. Progress depends on the skills being developed and the outcomes being pursued.
Expanded Answer
A student who is developing strong skills in rhythm, harmony, listening, improvisation, accompaniment and musical understanding is still making substantial progress.
The absence of an examination certificate does not automatically mean the absence of learning.
What matters most is whether the student’s efforts are helping them move towards the kind of musician they hope to become.
Quick Answer
Progress can be measured through increasing understanding, independence, confidence and musical capability.
Expanded Answer
Students often demonstrate growth in practical ways. They may learn songs more quickly, recognise musical patterns, accompany others confidently, create their own arrangements or understand harmony at a deeper level.
These achievements may not always appear on a certificate, but they are important indicators of genuine musical development.
In many cases, they reflect skills that students continue using long after formal assessments have finished.
Have you read?
Related Articles
- Classical vs Contemporary Piano for Teenagers
- Why Teenagers Often Lose Interest in Piano
- How Contemporary Piano Can Reignite Motivation
- Piano Lessons for Creative Teenagers
- Learning Piano Through Pop, Blues and Jazz
- Why Some Teenagers Thrive with Contemporary Piano
- From Classical Pieces to Real Music-Making
- What If My Teen Doesn’t Want Exams?
- Helping Teenagers Stay Motivated



